A few years ago we had a discussion about OA (Overeaters Anonymous) and Radiant Recovery. Are they compatible? Should you do both?
OA is patterned after AA, so it is based on the idea of setting down the problem [they define it as compulsive overeating] and learning a new life.
OA says, *we learn that we are 'powerless over food' and that the spiritual awakening of turning our lives over to a power greater than us could heal us.*
OA offers incredible fellowship and support. Its focus is on *abstinence*, or giving up sugar and white flour and creating an individual food plan that gets you there.
Here is the difference. RR does not believe that *powerlessness* is a good construct for women in particular. There is a core difference in the baseline. RR simply says that some of us have different bodies. That chemistry sets us up to respond to some food differently. *Food* is not the issue. And we are not powerless over *food*.
Food is good....And some foods set up a biochemical response that leads to compulsion and addiction.
But *we* are not *powerless*. If we heal the imbalance that leads to the addiction, then we are able to make profound life changes.Healing is about empowerment.
And personally, I have a major problem with the concept of *abstinence*...it is so negative and punitive. And if you *lose* abstinence, you have to start all over. How silly is that? Far better to approach healing as a process...you learn skills. You don't just stop sugar or compulsive eating. Stopping sugar is only a tiny part of healing. In RR we want you to heal. You learn to take tiny, nano steps so you succeed.
You count your recovery based on your COMMITMENT to heal, and not on abstinence.
Your struggles in RR become treasures to learn from. Your *relapse* becomes a teacher rather than a failure. Your *defects of character* are simply biochemically driven behaviors that just seem to get resolved as you do the food and learn to change behaviors. Now, I know this will sound silly, but I just had an awakening.
The 7th step in OA says, *humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings....* I have read this for many years in AA, this morning I read it at the OA site and I thought...this is so different from RR. I think the removal of the things we wish to let go of is what heals us. It is called taking responsibility.
My perspective is that doing the food is not grace's job. It is mine, LOL. I work on the food, I learn to take responsibility. I learn how to communicate, to do anger differently, to do intimacy differently. That is not grace's job, it is mine.
I think perhaps RR is less about spiritual conversion and more about practical ways to eat breakfast, to stop obsessing about SUGAR, including abstaining from it. And to start working with healing. What will I add today to make my life more full? How can I have shake on time?
How can I laugh, not take myself so seriously? How can I stop being afraid or ashamed of my addiction and simply kiss it on its black nose and say, come on darling, time for a different way? Let's use those fabulous addictive skills on behalf of healing.
Do I love the RR way? You bet I do. I love every part of it, every nuance, every scruffy little thing. It is informed by grace, by experience, by thousands of lives and by this deep knowing that addiction can be healed. And it is informed by those funny seven steps that work so well.
Can you do both? Of course. Many people do. If you have a group that will allow you to use the RR *plan* as your food plan, you can get the best of both worlds. But make sure you keep laughing. Laughter will heal you no matter what. And that potato helps too.